NHS Trusts need to maintain the capability to make informed capital investment decisions, regardless of funding constraints. Drawing on the experience of George Findlay, former Chief Executive of University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust, this article examines how strategic planning, cross-team collaboration and a clear view of service needs can help align investment with long-term clinical and operational priorities.
When NHS capital becomes available at short notice, Trusts may need to weigh an immediate funding opportunity against other demands on limited resources. Funding can be linked to specific performance improvements and timescales, creating pressure to identify schemes that can proceed quickly. Yet the scheme that is easiest to progress may not be the investment that offers the greatest long-term value.
For George Findlay, former Chief Executive of University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust, the main challenge is ensuring that capital planning starts with a clear understanding of what needs to change across the estate, why it matters to services and how investment can support those changes, rather than simply maintaining a list of projects awaiting funding.
Four broad categories provide a useful starting point for approaching these decisions: IT and digital infrastructure, medical equipment, critical backlog maintenance and strategic development. These areas, while representing distinct forms of capital demand, are closely connected. Investment in digital infrastructure and medical equipment, for example, can help sustain existing services while enabling changes to how care is delivered, with strategic development often drawing on these same areas to support longer-term changes to services and the estate.
Recognising how these areas are connected, however, does not make the allocation of capital any easier. With capital limited, investment in one area can leave less available for others, requiring Trusts to balance the risks of underinvesting in existing services and infrastructure against the need to prepare for future service requirements.
Operational pressure shapes capital decisions
NHS leaders operate under considerable operational and financial pressure. Revenue budgets, workforce challenges and performance requirements demand sustained attention, leaving limited time to consider investment needs that may not become urgent for several years. The imbalance is clear when capital spending is considered alongside the wider responsibilities of a Trust. A capital programme can receive relatively little board attention alongside the much larger revenue budget, even though decisions about the estate can have long-term consequences for service delivery.
The implications of these competing priorities become clearer when considering what a major capital scheme can achieve. In one large hospital development, new ward and theatre facilities expanded capacity, while other clinical and operational pressures remained and required further investment.
Developments of this scale can take many years to move from initial business case to completion, during which clinical and operational requirements may change considerably. This is not a judgement on the original decision, which reflected the circumstances and information available at the time. It does, however, underline the importance of understanding what a scheme needs to achieve from the outset and revisiting those requirements as plans develop, particularly as the scope to make substantial changes narrows once the design is fixed.
A smaller scheme involving both rebuilding and refurbishment took a different approach. With continuity of leadership and a clear view of the performance improvements needed, the team worked back from those outcomes, considering the clinical pathways and staffing model before determining the infrastructure required. It progressed more smoothly.
Maintaining the capability to develop investment options
During his time as Chief Executive, George’s team anticipated that short-term capital opportunities would become available, despite uncertainty over their timing and value. Maintaining a pipeline of potential schemes helped the organisation prepare, but this work needed to begin before a funding opportunity presented itself. That preparation requires Trusts to understand where services are experiencing pressure, what changes may be needed over time and how investment could address those needs.
A working document can help translate that assessment into a clearer proposal, setting out its purpose and requirements and providing a basis for deciding whether it warrants further development into an Outline Business Case (OBC) or a more detailed proposal.
A clearly defined service need may lead to several possible responses, and those options should remain open for consideration as circumstances change. Clinical services must be able to articulate their future requirements; operational teams need to identify the constraints affecting delivery; finance teams must assess affordability; and estates and capital planning teams need to understand the implications for infrastructure and delivery.
Sustaining this capability requires more than the preparation of individual proposals.Ā Continuity of strategic thinking, sustained engagement between clinical and corporate teams, and the organisational knowledge needed to understand changing service requirements are all important.Ā Without these foundations, investment planning can become episodic, driven by immediate pressures or funding opportunities rather than by a developing understanding of what the organisation needs.
Aligning existing assets with future service needs
Decisions about existing infrastructure need to reflect what the organisation intends to deliver in the longer term, as well as the risks it faces today.
Critical backlog maintenance illustrates the judgement involved. The classification of an issue as critical does not, by itself, determine the appropriate timing of intervention. Trusts still need to assess the risk, establish what action is necessary and consider the consequences of delaying work.
Any decision must also account for planned changes to the affected building or service. Where a facility is due to be reconfigured or replaced, investment in its existing fabric may need to be weighed against the risks of deferring work until the wider development takes place. The decision will depend on the asset’s condition, the timescale for change and the consequences for service delivery. Neither immediate expenditure nor deferral should be treated as the default response. Even when a particular investment is deferred, the organisation must remain satisfied that the associated risks are adequately controlled in the meantime. Deferring investment does not mean accepting an inadequately controlled risk.
Similar considerations apply to medical equipment and digital infrastructure, where replacement decisions should reflect clinical requirements and the future configuration of services, rather than simply an assetās age or condition.
Keeping investment decisions aligned with organisational strategy
For George, boards and executive teams need to keep longer-term investment needs on the strategic agenda. Boards rightly monitor expenditure against the annual capital plan, project milestones, delivery risks and forecast outturn. However, as George explains,
That oversight is necessary, but it doesn’t necessarily tell them whether the programme reflects the organisation’s longer-term clinical and operational priorities
Answering that question means understanding how priorities were established: the strategic assumptions behind the programme, the options considered and the trade-offs made, set against how clinical services, operational models, digital capability and the estate need to develop. It also means weighing what each choice implies for future operating costs, workforce requirements and service delivery, and what deferring investment would risk.
Boards should also seek assurance that clinical, operational, financial and estates teams have shaped proposals together, rather than a proposal having started with a building or an available funding opportunity, and they should be interested in the quality of the thinking and the evidence behind each proposal instead of judging it solely on whether individual business cases have been completed. This needs to be sustained through existing strategy and planning processes, with investment options revisited as demand, financial constraints and estate priorities change. For George, this is about the questions boards ask and the capability they expect the organisation to maintain, not necessarily additional governance structures, and about keeping a shared understanding of future service needs and credible options for meeting them, rather than simply accumulating business cases awaiting funding.
Capital may be scarce, but as George argues, these are precisely the circumstances in which Trusts need to preserve their ability to develop and test future investment options, so that when funding becomes available, decisions are guided by longer-term clinical and operational priorities, with the necessary preparation already in place to assess each proposal.